Review Process

The peer review process for journal publication is essentially a quality control mechanism. It is a process by which experts evaluate scholarly works, and its objective is to ensure a high quality of published science. However, peer reviewers do not make the decision to accept or reject papers. At most, they recommend a decision. At peer-reviewed journals, decision-making authority rests solely with journal editors or the journal’s editorial board. Indeed, it is the journal editor who is considered to be central to the decision making process.

Once a manuscript clears the initial screening, it is sent for peer review.

There are three common types of peer review for journal publication:

  • Single blind: names of reviewers are not revealed to authors
  • Double blind: names of reviewers and authors are not revealed to each other
  • Open peer review: Names of authors and reviewers are revealed to each other